The Chatner

The Chatner

Share this post

The Chatner
The Chatner
"It's Not A Sex Thing": The Chaste 'n' Plucky Heroine, Thwarted Again
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
User's avatar
Discover more from The Chatner
A newsletter about rejiggered classics, transmasculine underpinnings of the plucky heroine, and the failure-limits of graciousness, from table manners to family estrangement.
Over 20,000 subscribers
Already have an account? Sign in

"It's Not A Sex Thing": The Chaste 'n' Plucky Heroine, Thwarted Again

Daniel Lavery's avatar
Daniel Lavery
Apr 23, 2020
50

Share this post

The Chatner
The Chatner
"It's Not A Sex Thing": The Chaste 'n' Plucky Heroine, Thwarted Again
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
6
Share

YOU ARE A PLUCKY TOMBOYISH HEROINE RECENTLY COME OF AGE! ARE YOUR LEGS:

  1. Ungainly;

  2. Coltish;

  3. Sunburnt;

  4. Carrying you across the southeastern border of the hayfield as fast as lightning

YOUR SCALLAWAGGERY HAS GOTTEN YOU IN TROUBLE MANY A TIME AND OFT WITH YOUR SCHOOLMASTER/WITCH COUNCIL/THE MOON ELDERS:

  1. They wish I were more like my sister Glytemnestrae;

  2. How well-behaved and effortlessly feminine she is, never fidgeting at lessons;

  3. Her legs are never sunburnt;

  4. Perhaps…if I were to bind my breasts and disguise myself as a Boy….I could teach them all a lesson?

FATHER IS ILL:

  1. I shall bind my breasts and disguise myself as a Boy Doctor….I will prescribe powerful medicines and prove once and for all that girls with sunburnt legs can be trusted with prescription pads

  2. I shall bind my breasts and disguise myself as a Boy pedlar, smuggling myself Offworld on a caravan of thieves, in order to maintain the family fortune

  3. I shall bind my breasts and disguise myself as a Boy so that,

  4. I should really just bind my breasts over this, see if that helps bring Father’s fever down

  5. I mean it can’t hurt

  6. Don’t you want Father to get better, Glytemnestrae?

  7. Look, just as a general policy, you can assume that if anyone in the family gets sick, just to be on the safe side, I’m going to bind my breasts

  8. And get one of those great kind of flow-y tunic-y shirts that sometimes men wear, that are loose-ish but also practical and really highlight the manifold charms of the masculine torso

  9. And I’ll have a sick-as-fuck scar under my right eye and call myself Ranulph

  10. I mean…if it’ll help Father

  11. Did you know sometimes guys kiss other guys

  12. Listen, before you say anything, hear me out: First I bind my breasts so everyone thinks I’m a boy

  13. I’ll have a silky, streamlined chest, with rosy, masculine nipples the size of chestnuts

THE HARVEST IS AT RISK OF FAILING:

  1. Okay, well, I think we can all agree that what needs to happen is for me to bind my breasts

  2. To SAVE the FAMILY, of course

  3. You think I want to bind my breasts??

  4. Because this has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with what I want, Lalainne

  5. I’m just SPIRITED

  6. This is about proving how great girls are

  7. You have to call me Ranulph to prove that girls are just terrific

  8. How is anyone ever going to realize how great girls are unless I’m allowed to live on a ship with a man with a seasoned eye and a ruddy beard and I’m his cabin boy and my muscles grow hard from sea-work and he gruffly says “Ae ‘n work, lad” to me each night

  9. His arms are like barrel-staves

  10. Or maybe I’ll have to flee to Court, where I will be besieged by worldly-wise older women with impeccable personal style and beautifully fragrant arms

  11. And they’ll all flirt wildly with me according to an incredibly severe and minutely-watched code of conduct, such that every single word or act, no matter how small, is fiercely imbued with meaning and possibility

  12. The stakes will be impossibly high – my jawline impossibly sharp – my chivalry impeccable, my regard for the niceties faultless, my dress immaculate

  13. These women will be just unbelievably sexually experienced

  14. It’s not a sex thing

SOMETHING HAPPENED WITH THE KING OR SOMETHING OR A TREE FELL OVER MAYBE:

  1. Thank goodness I already had all of my breast-binding kit with me, otherwise who knows how long it would have taken me to jury-rig something out of a corset

  2. It’s only to further the causes of adventuring!

  3. I have to do it because of Society

  4. What I’m doing is actually VERY GOOD because it’s about keeping our nuclear family together and safe and definitely doesn’t have a sexual component to it

  5. Use your elaborate knowledge of Cosmeticks to fashion me a light beard, Marguerite

  6. Maybe someone will want to lick it later

THIS MATH PROBLEM IS HARD:

  1. Carry the 9….hang on, let me bind my breasts real quick, see if that helps

  2. I gotta run back to the house real fast, see if Father is ill…maybe Father is ill, or maybe he’ll be ill later….or maybe he’ll be asleep later…sleeping is kind of like being ill…if I go back to the house at midnight and Father is asleep, then I’ll know it’s time to run away to the capital city disguised as a boy so I can learn to become a card shark

  3. I wish I lived at the lighthouse with the Lighthouse-Master and that he shaved my throat suspiciously with a leather strop every morning, inspecting me scrupulously

  4. Which way to the lighthouse? I already bound my breasts this morning, can I be excused?


Subscribe to The Chatner

By Daniel Lavery · Thousands of paid subscribers
A newsletter about rejiggered classics, transmasculine underpinnings of the plucky heroine, and the failure-limits of graciousness, from table manners to family estrangement.
Will Sharp's avatar
50 Likes
50

Share this post

The Chatner
The Chatner
"It's Not A Sex Thing": The Chaste 'n' Plucky Heroine, Thwarted Again
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
6
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Siobhann Bellinger's avatar
Siobhann Bellinger
Apr 24, 2020

seriously, this is every YA book I wanted to read as a lass rolled into one

Expand full comment
Like (3)
Reply
Share
AmZ's avatar
AmZ
Apr 23, 2020

If I'm humming "Je suis le plus beau du quartier", it's just to add to my disguise as a young nobleman of the world.

Expand full comment
Like (2)
Reply
Share
4 more comments...
Jane Austen's Persuasion, Part III
Previously: Persuasion, parts I and II.
May 20, 2024 • 
Daniel Lavery
34

Share this post

The Chatner
The Chatner
Jane Austen's Persuasion, Part III
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1
I Am The Horrible Goose That Lives In The Town
yes I am the horrible creeping bag of sound that is the most worst to you!
Sep 24, 2019 • 
Daniel Lavery
200

Share this post

The Chatner
The Chatner
I Am The Horrible Goose That Lives In The Town
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
14
A Brief Account of the Crimes Committed by the Baby So Far in his Nine Months of Life
So young and yet so steeped in crime
Jan 9 • 
Daniel Lavery
457

Share this post

The Chatner
The Chatner
A Brief Account of the Crimes Committed by the Baby So Far in his Nine Months of Life
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
46

Ready for more?

© 2025 Daniel M. Lavery
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.