Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marina Haulover's avatar

At first I just assumed that reviewer resorted to Google for material when they perceived they were in danger of not hitting their word count, and then I wondered if the reviewer was just not up to the close reading required to develop a critique based upon literary merit, but now I’m wondering whether perhaps the Googling happened first and this whole pieced was a disingenuous ideological hit job?

Expand full comment
Kasey's avatar

“Oh reason not the need!” That wasn’t a book review; it was a play-by-play of Kadue’s own emotional attachment to one particular, inflexible, and literal-minded idea about the necessary relationship between author and narrator. What a great realization to share with a therapist! What an unhelpful take on the value and merit of a novel!

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts