12 Comments
User's avatar
puckworth bartleby's avatar

This. More "boylike" content, highlighting the moments boyishness is described with Anne Shirley-esque effusiveness. Please affirm my weird gay gender through literature. #representationmatters

Ryan Kenny's avatar

I am also just finishing book 13 - step for step! Not sure if it meets your strict criteria, but I thought of the last Jack post when I came to the description of the Diane's topgallant mast creaking under him - it seems Stephen is not the only source of commentary about his weight! At this rate he'll be ballast enough for a 74 by the end of the series

Thomas Gordanier's avatar

Thank you for mentioning Jagiello. Patrick O'Brien independently evolving the Mary Sue (Jagiello being beautiful and perfect and everyone loves him, except for being clumsy in a way that never causes any real consequences) cracks me up.

Unless it's not independent evolution, and O'Brien was aware of Trek fan culture... the timing works out!

JJW's avatar

ok FINE i'll read the aubreyad again...twist my leg why don't you....

VermiciousKnid42's avatar

I love the honest befuddlement the male characters express at Jagiello's attractiveness to the ladies. Impossibly handsome, long curly golden hair, dresses like a dandy and a voice like an angel, why he's practically a girl himself!

Aubrey O'brien's avatar

"Wonderfully offbeat and clever—The Chatner is a refreshing blend of humor, insight, and unexpected charm."

Sarah's avatar

This is the journalism the people (me) want. Those books, and the movie, were incalculably inspiring to me as a teenage girl and, subsequently, devastating to my social life. I wanted nothing more than to be an incompetent midshipman with a secret.

Anton's avatar

This is the exact literary gender audit I crave. I would now like a formal boyishness-to-page-count ratio chart, complete with a line graph showing Jack’s joy-to-weight curve as the series progresses. Also: “a girlfriend-in-a-sexy-big-shirt moment” is now canonically how I will describe Diana Villiers to anyone who hasn't read the series. Please consider a follow-up tallying who in the series is described as “like a monkey,” “like a hatstand,” or “like a dry bone.”

Savannah's avatar

i'm 60% of the way through master and commander and already 1.5 loblolly boys have died, very dangerous to be an actual boy, seemingly the most dangerous job on the ship although i don't know what loblollying entails

Daniel Lavery's avatar

also most of the loblolly boys are 50!

Jenny Smith's avatar

At work so I don’t have Desolation Island on hand, but isn’t the first quote under Diana actually about Louisa Wogan?

Daniel Lavery's avatar

You’re quite right! i’ll have to adjust my score!